When Hiring Goes Wrong: Why It’s Not Your Fault (And What to Do About It)

We've all heard the phrase: "You need to choose better."

It’s a message women are bombarded with in relationships, but it shows up in business too. When a hire goes bad, when someone you trusted undermines your business, or when a team member turns out to be nothing like who they said they were in the interview, the blame often falls squarely on the leader's shoulders.

But what if the problem isn't poor judgment?What if the real issue is something else entirely?

What Skilled Manipulators Do (and Why It Matters in Hiring)

As Dr. Natalie Jones, PsyD, LPCC®  an expert therapist in treating clients who have experienced narcissistic abuse, explains so clearly: the most dangerous manipulators play the long game.

They don’t show up with warning signs on their foreheads. They mirror your language. They say the right things. They build rapport, gain your trust, and subtly adapt themselves to your expectations.

It’s only once you’re emotionally or professionally invested that the mask starts to slip.

And by then, you’ve already hired them.

Sometimes, you see a red flag early on. But when you’re overwhelmed, optimistic, or just deeply in need of support, it’s easy to rationalize it away. After all, they’re saying the right things, right?

Why Business Owners Are Especially Vulnerable

When you’re a business owner, every hire matters.

You’re not just filling a seat. You’re protecting your brand, your livelihood, your team dynamic. You're often under pressure to scale, delegate, or fix something fast. That urgency creates the perfect opening for skilled pretenders.

And women in business? We often lead with empathy. We want to believe in potential. We give second chances. That strength can be used against us if we don’t have the right systems in place.

My Story: From Blame to Clarity

I’m Marci, the founder of CollabGenius. And I’ve been there.

I made bad hires. Not because I wasn’t experienced. Not because I didn’t interview carefully. But because I was vulnerable. I wanted help. I wanted someone to rise to the occasion. I listened to the pitch, and I bought in.

What I got were people who, once inside, did the opposite of what they were hired to do. Some actively harmed my business. And yes—I blamed myself.

Until I realized this wasn’t about poor judgment. It was about lacking the right lens to see what was really going on.

The Solution: A Better System

That’s why I built CollabGenius.

It’s not just another hiring tool. It’s a full behavioral data system backed by science and powered by custom AI. We generate behavioral data that reveals how someone actually contributes in a team — not just how they present in an interview.

One of the most powerful elements of using an assessment like CollabGenius is that it removes the emotional fog and reveals what’s real. The issue isn’t that business owners or leaders are misreading candidates — it’s that some candidates are actively misrepresenting themselves. Skilled manipulators mirror your language, project alignment, and perform just enough to pass an interview. But CollabGenius uses a structured, role-based behavioral assessment that can’t easily be gamed. It surfaces how someone truly contributes in a team. This objective, data-driven insight strips away the illusion and gives you a clear view of someone’s real ability to deliver — before you make the hire. That’s what protects your business from being misled, especially when the stakes are high.

You upload that data, add your client’s context, your insight, and our custom GPT translates it all into:

• Clear hiring recommendations
• Team fit analysis
• Coaching and development plans
• Strategic action steps

It streamlines the entire process from assessment to action. And it shows you who’s really going to help your business grow—before you bring them on.

Final Takeaway

If you've ever been burned by a bad hire, it's not a failure. It's a signal that you need a better way to see clearly, before it's too late.

CollabGenius gave me back control, clarity, and confidence.

It can do the same for you.

Let’s stop blaming ourselves for being manipulated.Let’s start building smarter systems that make manipulation irrelevant.

‍